An Open Letter To Justice Pratibha Rani From An Ex-JNU and Ex-FTII Student

Mohit Priyadarshi

Dear Madam,

Like millions of my fellow citizens, I was eagerly waiting for your interim verdict on the bail application of JNUSU president, Kanhaiya Kumar, who was wrongly framed in a “sedition” case by people in positions of power.

When I received the news that Kanhaiya was granted interim bail for six months by the Delhi High Court, I felt elated, partly because I was relieved at the fact that our judiciary was not yet compromised, and partly because I strongly believe that politically conscious students like Kanhaiya Kumar, Umar Khalid and Anirban Bhattacharya should have the right to organize peaceful events within the premises of a university, without being hounded either by the administration, or their event being vandalized by politically-conspiring elements from without.

In that regard, the release of Kanhaiya from jail reinforced my belief that, no matter how compromised the structures of our current state apparatus, the judiciary works as an autonomous unit within a democracy, one which bases its opinions squarely on facts.

But as ecstatic as I was at the news, I felt particularly disturbed when I read the entire court order. It left me with a lurch in my stomach.

I found the court order hilarious, like many of my friends, but I also found it equally disappointing.

Let me explain why.

Hilarious, because, I did not expect a court order regarding the bail of a student charged of “sedition” to start with a patriotic song from a Bollywood movie. From Upkar, to be precise, starring Manoj Kumar as the fearless, self-effacing “Bharat”. Are we to learn patriotism from Manoj Kumar — seriously?

Is that the level of our political discourse these days? Mere Desh Ki Dharti might be a good song, but are we to expect even courts indulge in jingoistic, needlessly melodramatic rhetoric, and not to talk about facts?

Court orders, as far as I know, are not vehicles for expressing one’s penchant for literature, or music, or even expound on one’s ideas of nationalism. They are meant to be based on evidence.

Why then, after all the furore that Kanhaiya’s case generated in the last fortnight or so, in the face of complete absence of any evidence in the possession of Delhi police against Kanhaiya, after doctored videos were legitimately sourced to a political aide of our MHRD minister and the newsrooms of some media channels, did the court still have to fall in the trap of defining the contours of the case in a reductionist, and absolutely fabricated, “nationalist” vs “anti-nationalist” binary?

Do you also think all people in our country are either “nationalist” or “anti-nationalist”, madam? Will you also leave no space for being grey?

I expected the court order to be driven by rationale, evidence, facts. I expected it to be sparse and precise, not laden with unwarranted hyperbole.

Be that as it may, you were of course fully entitled to make your observations.

But, just when I thought I had the read the worst part of the court order and would somehow swallow it like a bitter pill, I read this:

While dealing with the bail application of the petitioner, it has to be kept in mind by all concerned that they are enjoying this freedom only because our borders are guarded by our armed and paramilitary forces. Our forces are protecting our frontiers in the most difficult terrain in the world i.e. Siachen Glacier or Rann of Kutch.”

That makes my heart skip a beat, madam.

Do we have nothing better to do than to make our soldiers the pawns every time? First BJP did it, then Arnab Goswami, and now even the courts?

If a soldier is a nation’s ultimate martyr, shouldn’t we all be ashamed for not being stationed, like you say, at the Siachen Glacier or the Rann of Kutch?

Why does the soldier become a distorted prism to validate our own patriotism?

I think such an idea of nationalism is misplaced and dangerous. By its sheer logic, someone who is corrupt can praise soldiers and can be redeemed as a “nationalist”, while somebody who simply questions the state’s decision to position these same soldiers, and getting them killed in a war — sometimes against our own people — will be deemed “anti-national.”

As if that was not enough, you again emphasized the point about our soldiers when you wrote:

“Suffice it to note that such persons enjoy the freedom to raise such slogans in the comfort of University Campus but without realizing that they are in this safe environment because our forces are there at the battle field situated at the highest altitude of the world where even the oxygen is so scarce that those who are shouting anti-national slogans holding posters of Afzal Guru and Maqbool Bhatt close to their chest honoring their martyrdom, may not be even able to withstand those conditions for an hour even.

The kind of slogans raised may have demoralizing effect on the family of those martyrs who returned home in coffin draped in tricolor.”

Being a former student of JNU, I can tell you that holding an event on campus to discuss Kashmir and Afzal Guru’s fate does not mean students are keeping him close to their hearts. It is the ghost of Afzal Guru that haunts them. These are students merely asking pertinent questions about the so-called “trial” meted out to Guru which, in their understanding of the whole case, was not completely just. They are expecting our democracy — and our judiciary — to be accountable and transparent in its decisions. Is that a lot to ask in a democratic country?

Which essentially brings us to the following question: is discussing Kashmir and having an opinion about Kashmir an “anti-national” act in itself?

Because if it is, then it is certainly not a democracy we are living in.

Moreover, not only do you manage to emphatically undermine serious scholars like Kanhaiya Kumar, who have worked through countless obstacles to get the education they deserve, but you undermine the academy — one of the most important institutions of a functioning democracy.

Where will the world’s democracies be if student voices, progressive voices, and radical voices, are stifled with the butt of a surcharged — but nonetheless hollow — political discourse?

To conclude your court order, madam, you wrote the following:

“The investigation in this case is at nascent stage. The thoughts reflected in the slogans raised by some of the students of JNU who organized and participated in that programme cannot be claimed to be protected as fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression. I consider this as a kind of infection from which such students are suffering which needs to be controlled/cured before it becomes an epidemic.

Whenever some infection is spread in a limb, effort is made to cure the same by giving antibiotics orally and if that does not work, by following second line of treatment. Sometimes it may require surgical intervention also. However, if the infection results in infecting the limb to the extent that it becomes gangrene, amputation is the only treatment.”

You claim that the investigation is at a nascent stage, and yet you have managed to draw so many inferences from it at such an early stage?

You have gone so far as to suggest that student activism is an “infection” which needs to be cured before it “becomes an epidemic.”

Without even going into the completely flimsy analogy you draw here, madam, but as a student who has received education from three different public-funded institutions of our country, I would like to contend that student activism is absolutely essential for the well-being of a democracy.

The academy, and its students, do not live and breathe in a vacuum, but are part of a socio-economic landscape that they have every right to question and criticize. A nation of unthinking students and zombie patriots will forever stand in a rut, madam, eternally condemned to stagnation.

If students and teachers in a university do not question the status quo, do not look at alternative methods of alleviating oppression, do not create a space conducive to critical enquiry, then what kind of students do we wish to create?

We certainly do not want a nation full of sheep, madam.

To quote Terry Eagleton, a prominent literary theorist:

“The role of academia should be do challenge status quo in the name of justice, tradition, imagination, human welfare, the free play of the mind or alternative visions of the future. A critical reflection on human values and principles should be central to everything that goes on in universities, not just to the study of Rembrandt or Rimbaud.” 

As a former student of both JNU and FTII, two institutes of higher education which have forever stood as bastions of critical enquiry in our country, and which have recently found themselves becoming the centers of confrontation against the ruling regime, I would like to say that these two institutes have provided me with the courage, and the means, to question, agitate, and finally, contribute in a meaningful way towards the betterment of our people.

You may think I am speaking out of my turn, madam, but please don’t try to kill the student in me.

(The writer of this article is a former JNU and FTII student, a struggling filmmaker, and a blogger who covers politics and cinema in national and international blogs).

 

  • Balaji Kumar

    What a fairytale story…judiciary is not compromised…every ever in the world judiciary is to look after the rich and famous…

  • Swa

    This ftii student is good for nthn. Her understanding of law is poor. A decision of the court has obiter dicta n ratio decidendi. Obiter cn include opinions. N this website has compromised itself in Posting sch baseless meritless articles.

    • Priyanka Singh

      He’s good for quite a lot of things, his ability to think rationally, is just one among many. Again, it’s not a compromise, it’s an opinion piece. Obiter dicta etc. Please go back to your lawback and revise and write something coherent , atleast make some sense.

      • Trinacrianankh

        lol.. ur beloved jnu celebrated the massacre of 76 crpf men. That is the reason the judge included that point. Anyways, u feel so confident to judge the judge than you should take a certified copy of the order and challenge it before the principal judge and say that you dislike the choice of words of the judge. Please do that and come back to me on this comment section; Coz you erratic pseudo intellectuals cannot tolerate dissent of your opinions. And for any opinion given, it is not coherent to your sensibilities. Guess, studying in FTII and JNU has not been useful on you. You still in the stage of tabula rasa, where though you have learned everything, you still behave ignorant. Before dictating me your ideal way of writing ‘order’, first learn and understand judicia process.

        Also, Mr. Citizen Mann… there are several notable judgments that has quoted from renown poems, literature etc. So kindly, do not be so eager to pounce on anything which doesnt reason with your sensibilities.

        • Priyanka Singh

          Yes, JNU is my beloved university. Glad you figured that out and good to see you actually think and write this time. Who celebrated the massacre of 76 crpf men? If Zee news & Times Now are your credible sources for such information, I feel bad for you. One should not stay ignorant for so long, so I request you to utilise your time in actually reading about such things before you blatantly accuse others for your ignorance. Let’s continue this discussion once you actually do some reading because I cannot take someone seriously whose TV subscription is limited to Times Now.
          Also, quoting literature isn’t the point of contention of this argument. Quoting a patriotic song in a sedition case is just way too melodramatic.

          • Trinacrianankh

            Ok. Now every other news channel is conspiring in putting down your Jnu. If every news channel is against your point of view, then I guess your in a bubble, kid. I guess it is high time you wake up to reality and see that there is no such conspiracy. Your college has some flaws, tht u have overlooked. I do not want to speak anything further coz you are as blinded as other afzal lovers from ur college. If you think you are better than the judge and you should sit on the judge’s seat, then you should study abc of law first. If you are finding something melodramatic or not happening, then your shallowness in accepting things is poor.

          • Priyanka Singh

            Not every other, just the 2 I mentioned. Your favorite channel’s producer quit Zee because he admitted the videos were doctored. You’re just being lazy now, I’m not going to do your homework but just so that it helps you, whoever close to you watches more than 2 news channel, have a conversation with that person and get your facts cleared.
            The reason you can’t speak further is because you don’t have anything to say don’t blame that on me. I am pretty shallow but that’s beside the point. See that’s the problem in engaging with people like you in a dialogue. You quit because you don’t have any facts to support your argument. Best that you can come up with is name-calling. I don’t mid that everyday someone from your Sanghi camp does that, its your only refuge. But isn’t it sad to live in a world where your worldview is limited to lies. Don’t you even want to attempt to become a bit more aware of what’s happening around you. I’m not asking you to believe in every word I’m saying, I’m asking you , as a capable human being to educate yourself before you accuse anyone. Today its JNU tomorrow it can be your alma-mater. It’s not an individual struggle, this is bigger than you and me. It’s okay if you don’t intend to talk further, I just hope you heed to my advice anyway.

          • Trinacrianankh

            You are bloating that you know the news so well. My god, I am surprised with your know-it-all attitude. I guess you don’t know the latest lab report about the videos. Please spend few minutes on this link. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/2-of-7-JNU-video-clips-doctored-says-lab-report/articleshow/51234661.cms
            Now, is TOI conspiring too?

            Btw, I never said im quitting. I understand your troubled by what I am saying, and it isnt working out for you. Maybe, you know many things which I dont. Only a fool will admit to know everything. Btw, I keep my arguments in the court, n i really hate typing all this, while it is better to speak directly n create a context that way.

            If you didn’t want to engage in a dialogue with me, you should hv avoided commenting. It could have saved both of us a lot of time. The only name calling I did was call you a kid. Sorry, I will call you mam, though I am older than you. I know what is happening around me, more than you coz my line of profession requires that. I guess you being from ftii, shows that you are either working in the entertainment or media based industry, etc while I sign vakalaths and wait for justice to happen. I am more pragmatic that way, more so I dont have time for this conversation, but it was refreshing in talking to someone who strongly believes in her opinions. I dont see u giving any advise, but you should turn to urself and introspect. It was pleasant ‘disqus’sing with u here, i hope u have greater pursuits to attend to than whats happened. All the best.

          • Priyanka Singh

            Haha ‘It was pleasant ‘disqus’sing with u here’ good one there. I’m not from FTII. I’m a JNU alumni, yes. I am not from Media industry either. I’d love to discuss this over a coffee. Let me know when and where.

          • Jacob

            Hahaha

          • Sahana Vj

            haha…

          • Trinacrianankh

            Tht is very swt of u. Let me knw if ur in blore.

          • Mukul Dube

            A “practising advocate” who uses “bloating” for “gloating”? One, moreover, who hides behind a made up name…

          • Jacob

            Hehehe

          • Trinacrianankh

            So mr. Whoeveruare u decide wt i shd spk n wt name i shd keep.. N u think u can decide fr me.. Great.. U ve serious control issues.

          • Trinacrianankh

            Thank you

          • Jacob

            Well written

          • Sahana Vj

            Haha…..

          • Sahana Vj

            Just forget this trin…. what ever his name . He is not worth wasting time.

          • Lenny Joseph

            There is no doubt JNU is to India what Yale is to the US.
            However , it has not grown so intellectual that some of the students can convene a gathering critizing a constitutional body like “the supreme court” and call a divisional bench of judges as “Judicial killers”.
            And, as if mocking judges have become a fashion with the “so called” SOME intellectuals of JNU that even this open letter smacks of such mocking overtones.
            So, the judge Pratibha Rani should have consulted so called JNU scholars and penned down her judgement so that it should be to their liking.
            Well this is height of arrogance.

          • Trinacrianankh

            Rightly said.

          • Binoy Hoskote

            Furthermore, given the erratic and erroneous cases made but have to be heard in sequence…the judge is constrained to make the remarks so made in relevance of pending casse that still has to be resolved. SOON, when that is complete you’ll find that delhi police will be censured strongly like they have been so many times in the recent past for their puppeteered dog-on-leash performance on dictats of home ministry of modi govt. If you canb’ t make sense of this like I said before YOU ARE A GOAT.GO GRAZE IN YONDER FIELS, GRASS IS GREEN…..MAYBE TASTY FOR YOU….

          • Lenny Joseph

            It’s kind of amusing that you are abusing anybody whose opinion does not align with yours . Get a life Mr. If you love taking a verbal fight with filthy language, please find some places than these discussion forums to do so.

        • Binoy Hoskote

          YOU GOATS HAVE SUCH POOR SENSE OF COMPREHENSION…AS YOUR BHEJAS ARE ALREADY FRIED BEYOND REPAIR. THEY WERE RIDICULING THE FOOLISH HOME MINISTRY CAUGHT UNAWARES OF PATHANKOT TERRORISTS ON INDIAN SOIL , THAT TOO ON AIR FORCE BASE FOR 3-4 DAYS PRIOR TO THE ATTACK. BUT GOATS LIKE YOU ARE BEYOND REDEMPTION..UNEDUCATED ILLITERATE LOLLIPOP LICKING N SUCKING IS ALL THAT IS KNOW TO PEOPLE LIKE YOU…MANY AROUND HERE.

          • Swathi

            Seriously sir u can lick ur own lollipop before u chew on ur half grown brains. Stop abusing urself in such a forum.

        • Binoy Hoskote

          POINT REMAINS HE IS OUT…AND THE COURT ORDER HAS BEEN BUFFERED NOT HURT THE SENTIMENTS OF THE TOTALLY FAULTED GOVT. BUT YOU ARE AN IGNORAMUS.

      • Vivek

        Arey Bhai Kanhaiya Kumar hume bi bta do……..

        Did Communist gave AZADI FROM GAREEBI to ppl of Bengal in 34 yrs of Communist RULE ?

        • Binoy Hoskote

          68 years, what the hell did cong and bjp gi9ve the people of india- bullshit”? now again what has pm modi done…name a few achievements other than braGGING, GLOBVETROTTING AND FAILURE IN FDI, LAND ORD. OROP,FLOPPED FOREIGN POLICY,PROMISED VADRA JAIL, ENDED RELEASING HIM QUOTING FALSE CASE…WRITING OFF ₹1,13,000 LAKHS CRORES NPA-DEBTS OF BIG BIZ-OF WHICH 65000 CROREES WAS OF ANIL AMBANI………WANT MORE NONSENSE DONE? HERS A COUPLE MORE…..SWATCHYA GANGA ₹4000CRS SPENT NOT AN INCH CLEANED….ATAL BIMA, JANDHAN YOJANAS A TOTAL FAILURE. TALKING OF GIVBING LPG GAS TO BPL AT SUBSIDIZED RATES WHEN A FAMILY HARDLY GETS ₹700 PM TO SURVIVE…WHAT PRICE WILL HE GIVE LPG AND AS THOUGH THEY CAN [PAY? HEI9IGHT OF FOOLISHNESS…..BPL USE WASDTE DRIED BRRANCHES, TWIGS TO FIRE THEIR CHULAAS. WHY CAN’ HE TALK OF GIVING THEM ONE FREE GAS CYLINDER EVERY MNONTH…I WOULD HAVE PRAISED PM MODI TO THE SKY… SO STOP BULLSHITTING YOU GOATS…

    • Sayalur

      Make sure you add this comment in your CV when you apply for a job! comment that you are very intelligent and you write stuff that no body except lawyers understand!

      • Trinacrianankh

        Good work Sayalur. I am a practising advocate.

        • Sahana Vj

          You an advocate? God save India ..

          • Trinacrianankh

            Lol

    • Sharad Vohra

      Ha ha. Quoting latin is quite in keeping with this medieval order. The judge should have rather confined the words to the merit of the case, on applicability of sedition charges being referenced to learned previous interpretations of the Supreme Court. Rather, used this pulpit also as an indictment to the men in black who acted like hooligans. Not adding fuel by exceedingly misplaced gangrene and amputation comments. Can we think this judge is not already swayed either by personal beliefs or a much more sinister design? No.
      Will these extraneous comments be petitioned and expunged. You bet.

      • Trinacrianankh

        Hmm.. Guess this post n comments shd b made a part of the contempt petition

    • Binoy Hoskote

      What the hell do you know of law? Just yapping is not law. Take a point of issue and comment, or you are trash.

      • Swathi

        I keep my arguments limited oly inside a court. N tht is one of the ethics a lawyer must maintain, sadly u ll be ignorant of tht. Anyways ur bad mouthing n harassing me here is enf to show what kind of a man ur n hw developed ur intellect is. Nyways, have a great day.

      • Swathi

        Thank u for ur kind suggestion sir.

  • Citizen Mann

    Justice should only be given in the context of constitution and not on the collective conscience of the nation

  • apolitical

    someone please forward it to the judge for her reply to the nation.
    For those bhaktos who keep saying students are wasting taxpayers money…..
    Bihar Movement was a movement initiated by students in Bihar in 1974 and led by the veteran Gandhian socialist Jayaprakash Narayan, popularly known as JP, against misrule by— and corruption in— the government of Bihar. It later turned against Prime Minister Indira Gandhi’s government at the centre.[1][2] It was also called Total Revolution Movement and JP Movement.[3]

    • Sayalur

      Besides seconding your opinion, Bhakti keep saying “their” money is being wasted! There are also other people who are paying taxes and are not opposing their views!
      Its just a gimmick from US politics!

    • Binoy Hoskote

      these uneducated hypocritical lot whose bheja has been fried and earen by bjp rss are left stuffed with BHUSSA-AS-BRAINS.and now turned into a liability.

      • Lenny Joseph

        And you are the most Educated (as opposed to uneducated) and genuine (as opposed to hypocritical) whose brain is clean with noble ideas by a political party of your choice who have instilled nothing but Abuse and ideologies to support terrorist and separatists. I doubt your ideologies will ever materialize and you will be a happy lot.

    • Lenny Joseph

      One chooses an agenda for launching a career in politics. Choosing separatists ideology and speaking up for terrorists who further the separatists’ cause can launch him a political career which will not do for the country as well its citizens. In contrast , Kejriwal was even smarter to choose “corruption” as his political agenda.

  • Sankar

    All is fine in this article except that Kanhaiya is a “serious scholar”. He is nothing of the kind. He is an activist who seeks a career in politics through rabble, shorn of reason.

    • Subodh

      Is seeking career in politics or being an activist wrong? If the most important tasks of policy making is being done by politicians, we do require that the finest of minds, the best of students from our universities go in politics. And, remember someone who is a bookworm, will not make a good politician. The person has to have passion for what he believes, the person need to have guts to withstand the power that the state and people will will exercise. I agree with you, Kanhaiya may not be a scholar, who will write history with his pen. But, he is the kind of scholar who will write history with his deeds.

      • Sankar

        Three cheers to Kanhaiya Kumar, hip, hip, hooray.

    • Sayalur

      “shorn of reason?”: Let me guess- You are writing because everyone else is writing and afraid of being left out!

    • Trinacrianankh

      True, many Phd’s are jobless. He is scaling to get into a political party instead of being a roadside activist.
      PhD holders among 23 lakh applicants for peon jobs in UP. Though his family earns a meagre 3k a month, he still carries an iphone, wears branded shoes and clothes, and has the highest paid lawyers in the country to roll him out of jail.

      http://www.hindustantimes.com/india/phd-holders-among-23-lakh-applicants-for-peon-jobs-in-up/story-OqHzHbvo16gUN2DfTkfYlI.html

      • Nishant Nandan Singh

        If you have got terms like “Roadside activists” in your vocab..I can only feel sorry for you ! Btw Who are real activists according to you ?? Just curious..

        • Trinacrianankh

          Roadside activists attract media attention. True activists file a PIL and get their way thru legal battle.

          • Lenny Joseph

            Absolutely….

      • Sahana Vj

        I feel sorry for people like u.

        • Trinacrianankh

          U basically ve nothing to comment. Yet u write coz u dont want to be left out

    • Sahana Vj

      Did he tell you he is seeking a career in politics? Hey stop making assumptions.

      • Trinacrianankh

        U shd watch his interview he gave with rajdeep Sardesai yesterday. He said that getting into politics is not his choice, bt the choice of the society. So he ll land up in politics sooner or later.

        • Binoy Hoskote

          So what’s wrong with that. We have rogues in politics…Why not fresh thinking scholarly students?

          • Swathi

            Just a couple of Questions to be answered:

            1. Apparently Kanahiya is 28yrs old. Even a Phd program or MD medicine gets done by 28 yrs. JNU has no base to teach technical things. Wonder what course he is doing which is never ending or does not intend finishing?

            2. Students coming from middle class families get down to working by 25 or latest by 28 yrs. This guy comes from such a poor background wonder how he can afford it not to work and earn?

            3. Now he hires the country’s best lawyers to defend him, wonder who is footing the bill and why?

            4. Most of these so called JNU students register in universities to avail subsidised hostel stay & subsidised canteen food. Why should our tax money be used for such students who occupy the hostel permanently and deserving students have to look for PG accommodations. Why the tax payer be burdened with tax for these guys. Let the respective political party fund their fun.

            5. He went for 3 months campaigning for Bihar elections. Wonder what happened to classes and who funds this?

            6. Please realise these are not students. They are politicians in making, let them fight it out. Why is India being punished by their rubbish news on TV & newspaper. Only for TRP.

            7. All they want is to destabilise the growth for vested political interest of the opposition.

            8. They are not innocent students by any stretch of imagination. Nor are they genuine.

          • Lenny Joseph

            Politics for the country and its welfare is a service to the country and fellow citizens but only if the politics carries good intention. Getting into politics by eulogizing convicts and terrorists and furthering secessionist ideology does not reflect noble intentions.

    • Lenny Joseph

      If you think… at 28 years he is still doing a full fleged course/thesis ..and have never been seen a life beyond being a student….and on top of he has time for all these…then when is he having time to do his research. Nobody wants to get personal but here we are forced to introspect and I don’t think he has a life beyond doing cheap politics. Politics itself isn’t bad , it depends on people. Mahatma Gandhi was a politician and so is Lalu Prasad ( a thief) or Mulayam (a gunda)…

      • Trinacrianankh

        30 yrs n still doing nothing.. Kuch logo ko umar badti hai lekin samaj nahi

  • Balanced

    Who is stopping you to discuss if to discuss Kashmir and Afzal Guru’s fate. Please discuss brain storm and exercise your freedom . But who are you to declare him Martyr. Further its great thing that you invite someone at your house. Then ask those unknown guests to shout anti india slogans. then say they were outsiders as captured in Video and police should catch hold of them and not you being the owner of the house.Then why cant it be told that please show the video where you stopped them from shouting those slogans? Dont fool around and insult Indian citizens. And just dont have binary approach . every one is not bhakt who is pained by this.

    • Hindusthani

      Lets try to think it together.
      Question 1. Do we have proof that any one of the arrested students declared Afzal Guru a martyr?
      Question 2. Do we have proof that these arrested students asked the outsiders to shout Anti India slogans?
      Question 3. Why did the ABVP students who invited Zee News to this event, not catch hold of this outsiders?
      Question 4. Why is the police not making a case against Zee News for misleading them? This probably prevented them from capturing the real culprits?
      Question 5. Is the real reason that police are not capturing the real culprits because this will lead to a problem for the BJP in forming a government with PDP who consider Afzal Guru a martyr?

      • Lenny Joseph

        Question 1. Do we have proof that any one of the arrested students declared Afzal Guru a martyr?
        (a)The poster that was distributed contained this piece (there is no dispute that posters were found all around the campus):
        “Against the judicial killing of Maqbool Bhat and Afzal Guru”..
        (b) Khalid Umar , a doctoral student of JNU, has been found shouting …”tum kitne afzal maroge ghar ghar se afzal niklega”.
        (c) the event has the support and more from Kanhaiya Kumar is evident (hence proved) from the talk show hosted by Rohit Sardana , where Kanhaiya Kumar tries to defend Afzal by taking refuge of derive “Against Death Penalty” which is a pretext because the event was not for “Against Death Penalty” but “Against Judicial Killing of Afzal Guru”.
        Question 2. Do we have proof that these arrested students asked the outsiders to shout Anti India slogans?
        – Its not proof , its inference.
        When some section of assembled people shouted slogans , being the president/secratary etc of the students union , they have all the power to stop the non-sense.
        It went on and infact got vigorous with time and these people were seen part of the assembly.
        Some of them were actually relishing (like Khalid Umar).

        Question 3. Why did the ABVP students who invited Zee News to this event, not catch hold of this outsiders?
        – I am not sure what are the role of ABVP here. I have got to know that , it was at ABVP’s behest that event was called off by the administration in the morning of 9th Feb 2016 but the organizers did not abide by it and went ahead disregarding the dictate.
        Question 4. Why is the police not making a case against Zee News for misleading them? This probably prevented them from capturing the real culprits?
        – Did anybody logde a complain against Zee News?… I haven’t heard anybody doing it. I believe if Zee News have tried to temper facts , there should be an FIR or PIL ..whatever.

        Question 5. Is the real reason that police are not capturing the real culprits because this will lead to a problem for the BJP in forming a government with PDP who consider Afzal Guru a martyr?
        – Seems like ‘Yes’ BJP have a political ambition and that is what saving these slogan hurling kashmiris . BJP is not a great party either but Congress did not even try to think for the progress of the country and looted the country left and right with billions of dollars of scam.

        Bottomline, is these students did give separatist a plaftform to further their secessionist ideology and hence whatever is happening to them is deserving.

        • Binoy Hoskote

          NOTHING WAS SAID AGAINST DEATH PENALTY…BUT HASTE -OUT OF TURN EXECUTION YOU STUPID IDIOT.MILLIONS OF PEOPLKE ACROSS THE WORLD ARE GENERALLY AGAINST DEATH SENTENCE AS A FORM OF PUNISHMENT-AND EVEN IF KANHAIYA DID SAY THAT IT WAS NOT QUESTIONING HIS GUILT BUT PENALTY LIKE WORLD SEES DEATHP[ENALTY. IF YOUR ENGLISH IS POOR AND YOUR COMPREHENSION IS STILL WORSE, THEN YOU ARE A HUSSA BRAIN WHO HAS LOST HIS BRAINS SINCE BJP & RSS HAVE MADE BHEJA FRY OUT OF YOUR BRAINS…SO SHUT UP.

          • Lenny Joseph

            Abusing somebody in a public forum does not make you a hero and at the same time does not demean anybody like BJP, Congress or RSS or even me. I am not here to write flowery english to please you.
            Coming to the point, so according to you , Kanhaiya Kumar is against death penalty , even I am against death penalty , 147 countries have abolished it and so should India consider to ban it. But my point is , the gathering was for “Against Judicial Killing of AFZAL GURU” not againt “Death Penalty” . Why on earth should the example be just AFZAL GURU and why “judicial killing”? So the judges were killers?
            You have just the guts to abuse someone in public forum that’s it , if you could gather the guts to do it in streets you will join SAR Geelani in jail…

          • Swathi

            I agree with u lenny.

        • DrChandra Mauli Jha

          Pointedly logical thinking Mr. Lenny and Mr. Balanced.
          It is misfortune of modern India that dishonesty has gripped strongly those who should be Honest and deep thinker. By claiming that one is from JNU does not make a scholar. ..”that which cuts has an edge”… A rusted knife made of best class of steel may not have that.
          The very problem with person like Mohit is that they always try to classify the problem / issues before attempting to understand the demand of the problem.
          Judge had asked Kanhaiya on the day of first appearance about kind of freedom they wanted to which he was speechless.
          Living on others resources is parasitism. Doing something else than what I was expected to do and what I have accepted to do is cheating. These two are character traits of Kanhaiya. Actually it is not all his fault. His teachers and guide are doing same. Probably kanhaiya could never understand the difference between cheating and honesty, between compassion and hate, between help and bait. He is victim of his own fantasies which are being nurtured by his transient successes. He would remain busy caring for his political masters than his parents. May God help him!

        • Hindusthani

          Question 1. Do we have proof that any one of the arrested students declared Afzal Guru a martyr?

          (a)The poster that was distributed contained this piece (there is no dispute that posters were found all around the campus):

          “Against the judicial killing of Maqbool Bhat and Afzal Guru”..

          (b) Khalid Umar , a doctoral student of JNU, has been found shouting …”tum kitne afzal maroge ghar ghar se afzal niklega”.

          “I am not sure if he has said such things. Still he is not calling him a martyr or a freedom fighter.”. Please let me have a link if you have proof.
          (c) the event has the support and more from Kanhaiya Kumar is evident (hence proved) from the talk show hosted by Rohit Sardana , where Kanhaiya Kumar tries to defend Afzal by taking refuge of derive “Against Death Penalty” which is a pretext because the event was not for “Against Death Penalty” but “Against Judicial Killing of Afzal Guru”.

          Yes, there are learned legal people having an opinion that perhaps the death penalty was not the correct punishment in the case of Afzal Guru. Only Kanhaiya can know where he stands on this. And we are not supposed to be controlling what people think by beating them up.

          Question 2. Do we have proof that these arrested students asked the outsiders to shout Anti India slogans?

          – Its not proof , its inference.

          When some section of assembled people shouted slogans , being the president/secratary etc of the students union , they have all the power to stop the non-sense.

          It went on and infact got vigorous with time and these people were seen part of the assembly.

          Some of them were actually relishing (like Khalid Umar).

          It is important to remember that there is a history of ABVP versus AISA politics in JNU. ABVP students were also taunting the outsiders. I am not sure if you have been involved in students politics but it is never a clever idea for the President take sides and use force during a slogan shouting match between two groups of students. The President does not carry any power, if he takes sides – he can end up being beaten. He just fights for students issues with the University authorities. Thats about it.

          Question 3. Why did the ABVP students who invited Zee News to this event, not catch hold of this outsiders?

          – I am not sure what are the role of ABVP here. I have got to know that , it was at ABVP’s behest that event was called off by the administration in the morning of 9th Feb 2016 but the organizers did not abide by it and went ahead disregarding the dictate.

          Please google and read with an open mind, you will find that ABVP is not an innocent party in this.

          Question 4. Why is the police not making a case against Zee News for misleading them? This probably prevented them from capturing the real culprits?

          – Did anybody logde a complain against Zee News?… I haven’t heard anybody doing it. I believe if Zee News have tried to temper facts , there should be an FIR or PIL ..whatever.

          The Police is clearly taking sides in this matter and has already prejudged the students to be anti national. Why was Zee News allowed inside the Campus without permission from the VC?

          Question 5. Is the real reason that police are not capturing the real culprits because this will lead to a problem for the BJP in forming a government with PDP who consider Afzal Guru a martyr?

          – Seems like ‘Yes’ BJP have a political ambition and that is what saving these slogan hurling kashmiris . BJP is not a great party either but Congress did not even try to think for the progress of the country and looted the country left and right with billions of dollars of scam.

          If you accept that BJP has a political ambition, then does it not make sense that ABVP which is its student wings wants to trap some JNU students to keep quiet about Rohith Vemula and other such issues. Congress for all its corruption at least is not dividing the country on communal lines just for the sake of some votes. This is more dangerous in my view then corruption.

          Bottomline, is these students did give separatist a plaftform to further their secessionist ideology and hence whatever is happening to them is deserving.
          Yes, I agree Afzal Guru should not be given a Martyr Status which the arrested students did not but the way forward is to convince them through debate and discussion. Not through unnatural use of state machinery.

          • Lenny Joseph

            1. I again reiterate posters were floating around everywhere and Kanhaiya did nothing to stop it.
            Regarding implication of “Khalid Umar” in shouting slogans in support of Afzal guru:
            I saw a live talk show by Rohit Sardana where he was charging Khalid of shouting the said slogan and Mr. Khalid was defending himself. The recording is available in youtube :

            Somewhere you advised me to google and have an open mind, well I try to stay away from personal remarks like this. Here you imply that I do not have an open mind. I got this piece by googling only because the live show was over. Will appreciate if you would avoid personal attacks.

            2. As I said somewhere in this forum , “Death Penalty” should be abolished as it is done in 147 countries , however, that does not allow Kanhaiya to be mute spectator of a gathering speaking against Supreme court and terming Judges as “Killers”.

            3. Well politics in colleges is a well-known activity. Most of the students in govt. colleges/universities have affiliation to mainstream parties NSUI , AISA , AVBP , BVS (bharati vidarthi sena) etc… but there has to be a line drawn. President of a students union carries responsibilities beyond party affiliation. Before even he is anything (President, Student , member of some student group) , he is a citizen of the country. He enjoys power to involve college security anytime , he does not need to involve himself to stop the sloganeering. He did nothing to stop those “destroy india” slogans.

            4. I am not trying to defend any telecast company but they usually are not prevented from covering any event which is not a private one. I do not think there has been any complain against Zee News for covering it. Taking legal recourse is always an option if somebody have violated any privacy. Let the VC sue Zee News. 2 out of 7 videos were found doctored but evidence from the undoctored ones have been found good enough to keep Khalid and Anirban in jail.

            5. I am aware of Rohith Vemula’s incident. But the JNU incident on 9th February have no reference to Rohit Vemula suicide. People are trying to relate this later when they were cornered . If discrimation against Rohit Vemula was their motive, they should have had a gathering centered on that and there would not have been this ruckus. These are lame excuses to take refuge of “Death Penalty” , “Rohith Vemula” to evade the question of “Anti-India” activities.

          • Hindusthani

            Hi Lenny, Let us remember that we can have difference of opinion but we belong to the same country and we are the same people. I had no intention of making personal remarks. I just said please google the involvement of ABVP with regards to Zee TV and then try understand that they are also not innocent in this particular incident. Open mind because the media would like us to think in a certain manner, in this case, it is proved that Zee News entered the campus on invitation from ABVP and then ran a doctored video continuously. News Channels are not supposed to go inside Campus especially not in such a deliberate manner. Why such involvement of a political party (ABVP) and a news channel. It is clearly deliberate and with a planned agenda. Even Rohit Sardana has two students versus the BJP/RSS in this debate. I do not care for Kanhaiya or Umar’s views, they are just two students whom no one would have even heard of but for this media attention. However, I cannot see them as anti national or wasters of tax payer’s money just because Zee TV and ABVP wants me to believe they are. I realize that their views cannot hurt a huge nation like India. In a country, there will be many who will disagree with each other and we cannot start calling each other anti national. RSS did not have the Indian Flag on their headquarters because they did not like the pluralism it represented. They wanted only one color, that was saffron. Is this not against the very foundation of this country? The country belongs to each and every one of us. But we cannot simply shut people up because they have a different opinion.

            By the way, we should be discussing why billions of dollars worth of debt has been taken off from 39 corporate defaulters while the farmers die of suicide as they cannot pay their loans. Why is there no discussion on this in the parliament? Why there is no discussion on Black Money? It seems the media and the politicians do not want the people to focus on real issues but divert people with emotional issues of Nationalism so that the real issues are not discussed and some people will gain and the nation will loose.

    • Binoy Hoskote

      YOU ARE A BOODY FOOL. PDP SEPARATISTS WORSHIPPED & LATER DECLARED AFZAL GURU A MARTYR YOU GOAT. YOUR MODI GOVT. ARE GUILTY OF SEDITION & ANTI NATIONALISM FLIRTING & FORMING GOVT. WITH A SEPARATIST PARTY – PDP – WHO FAVOUR AZAD KASHMIR., MODI GOVT VIRTUALLYENDORSED AFZAL GURU WORSHIP & MARTYRDOM ALONG WITH PDP. ALL THIS IS WITH CONCRETE PROOF OF SEDITION. …………IN JNU CASE, WITH NO PROOF ZILCH- FROM THYE START TO FINISH TODAY- THERE IS NOY AN IOTA OF EVIDENCE OF SEDITION AGAINST THE STUDENTA- BUT MODI GOVT. WENT WHOLE HOG IN BLINDLY WRONGLY CONDEMNING AND ACCUSING SEDITION IN THE MOST UNDIGNIFIED FASHION, WHICH HAS EARNED PM MODI LASHINGS FROM ALL ACROSS THE WORLD. WHAT A SHAME …..
      WHERE ARE THE PLANTED ABVP GOONS SHOUTING PRO PAKISTAN AND ANTI INDIA SLOGANS TO CAST ASPERSIONS ON JNU STUDENTS, AS THOUGH JNU STUDENTS HAD SHOUTED…..IS OUR HOME MINISTRY RAJNATHSINGH AND DELHI POLICE SO IMPOTENT -NOT ABLE TO TRACE THEM TILL DATE ? EVEN AFTER 3 WEEKS? THEY WERE IMPOTENT TO ALLOW DOZEN GOONDA LAWYERS COWARDLY RATS THRASHING ONE STUDENT WITH THE POLICE LOOKING ON ENJOYING A STREETSIDE TAMASHA? THEY TOOK THEIR SWEET TIME TO ARREST THEM AND HELP THEM OUT ON BAIL FAST EVEN WITH CONCRETE PROOF. PEOPLE ARE LOSING TOTAL FAITH IN BJP & PM MODI AND CONSEQUENCES WILL BE SEN IN ALL FORTHCOMING ELECTIONS – ALREADY 14 ELECTIONS AT DIFFERENT LEVELS HAVE BEEN LOSTG BY BJP IN SPITE OF MODI. MORE LOSES, AND IN 2019 – IT;S GOODBYE …………CAN ONE IMAGINE GREAT CBI INVESTIGATING PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DELHI GOT-RAJENDER KUMAR FOR NTHE LAST 2 MONTHS WITHOUT ANY OUTCOME? WHAT EFFICIENCY CBI HAS LERFT…THEY RAIDED 10 PLACES WASTED TIME OF 20-30 OFFICERS, SPENT LAKHS OF RUPEES AND TILL DATE THWYE HAVEN’T ANY GROUNDS TO FILE CHARGE SHEET? IS NO ONE ASHAMED OF THE STATE OF AFFAIRS OF THIS COUNTRY PM MNODI HAS BROUGHT ABOUT ? ……………PM MODI GOVT MADE A MINCEMEAT OF CENTRAL GOVERNANCE. WAH MODIJI WAAH.. KYA GOVERNANCE KIYA AAPNE… TOO BUSY PROTECTING THE ABVP VAGABOND ROGUES…..
      MORE SHAMEFUL IS THE FACT THAT RSS,+ FANATIC WINGS + BJP ARE DISTORTING AND DESTROYING THE TRUE GREAT VALUES OF HINDUS & SAFFRON SANCTITY.

      • Lenny Joseph

        The basic problem with the whole JNU episode is that the real issue is getting subsided and its taking a political hue. For citizens like me , the concern is hurling abuse to my country. Congress / BJP are just a part of my country and hence unlike you , every citizen should think what happened in JNU was right or wrong. If its wrong , what can be done so that this does not repeat again. If you are so bent on taking a political stand , I don’t think this JNU case should be the right one to do that, you can choose a better place to hurl your political abuses and bring Modi and rahul into the discussion.

      • DrChandra Mauli Jha

        Your language suggests that you are from slum. It is not your fault but your fault is that you are still decided to continue in that slum. If you chose to go back to school and begin learning again, you would certainly do a favour to yourself.

  • Sayalur

    All those of you, who were offended by so-called “anti-national” comments, what have you done to be so “pro-national”?
    If sympathizing with a terrorist is so offensive, how many of our politicians are criminals. Sympathizing with criminals is ok, is it?
    On any given day, corruption kills more people than terrorism. Even religion comes in the list between!

  • Edwin Sequeira

    A number of journalists who are being used as propaganda tool of ‪‎Sanghis‬ got scalded irreparably by the ‪JNU‬ issue…The top 4 are in the poster. Credibility gone, their power to brainwash is no more and they have become a liability to the establishment….Time ticking for them…

    P.S.: They are also better known as ‪‎Presstitutes‬

    Tags: ‪ShamelessSmriti‬ ‪‎DoctoredVideos‬ ‪‎BraindeadBhakts‬ ‪Bhakts‬

  • kiranbade

    पाहली बार बगर ग्लीसारीन्के किसी अभिनेत्री को रोते देखा ,,,, क्या नाटक है ……..

  • Vivek

    Few Drug addicts and Sex maniac students and professors of JNU dont represent Voice of Youth of India.

    • corruption free India

      It seems you are also one of those sanghis who have gone to JNU to collect and count used condoms

      • Roy

        And you seem like one of those sex and drug addict commies.. I hope u sister not studying in JNU or at least she is not part of this red brigade. I m sure u have heard or may be living their life.

        • corruption free India

          level of your imagination tells me that you certainly live in a gutter…shame on your parents for producing such a creep. Must be something in the genes. Are you also mass producing your prototypes for the next generation and continuing with your pseudo-patriotic duties to Bharat Mata?

          • Roy

            Well wherever I live I respect t that, at least I m not those traiters like u people who are living out of publics money in Indian university at bloody 11 rs yearly rent and then swearing and cursing same country… Ashamed be those parents who gave birth to traiter scums like u people. Jis thali mai khate ho usi mai hug rahe ho aur dusro ko sharminda hone bol rahe ho. Bloody communist Ne Kolkata especially and bengal as whole ki kya hasr Kar di dikhta nahi hai aur salo scholar kahte ho khud ko. Aur jisne bhi south Delhi khas Kar ke Munirka raha hai use pata hai kya Randi bazi karte ho tum log hostels mai.. Bhasmasur diwas and victory day jab hamare jawans mare tav manate ho..
            Ek bhi ristedaar army mai hota to ehsas hota tum logo ko deshbhakti kya cheejo hoti hai aur itni desh bhakti to kisi jahil mai bhi hota hai ki desh Maa hoti hai use gali nahi deni chahiye..
            Dusro ke tukdo pe palke usi ko kata nahi karte ye gali ke kutto ko bhi pata hota hai.. Tum log unse bhi gaye ho. Jaa ganja wala cigerate mar aur ye chutiyapa apne hostel room thak rakh.. Apni Gandhi soch bahar failayega to Abhi thak sirf vakilo se peeta hai baad mai pura desh peetega..

          • corruption free India

            Why don’t you try to get some basic education at least in formal logic. Then at least you will be able to differentiate between a meaningful debate and blurting out profanities, like most of those sanghis doing these days. BTW, the country belongs to also 69% “minority” who didn’t vote for 31% “majority” of pseudo-Hindus who only know how to abuse and nothing else. If your underdeveloped brain understands the possibility of proportional distribution, then you will understand that many of the soldiers who are defending the country belong to that 69%. Thugs from the pseudo-patriotic sangh parivar murdered the father of such an army personnel in Dadri. But, writing more to a semi-literate person like you is futile who only knows how to chant om NaMo NaMo 100 times a day and the remaining time spends on abusing people.

          • Roy

            Again like other congi and commies u just said RSS killed akhlaq.. 🙂 why the hell u guys such name corruption free India etc. Ek corruption crusader kejriwal kam tha logo ko sutiya banne ke liye. Ab seedha naam rakhoge to jyada achha hoga public ko samajhne ke liye jaise congress B team, CPI C team, ya AAP part 2 … Stop fooling around with people. By the way u might have ignored a boy hanged himself in UP due to atrocities of college staff, just few days after akhlaq dalit child was burnt alive, riots happened in WBand Bihar only after a statement of Kamlesh tiwary.. But all these news never happened to be of ur political advantage so u just ignored it..
            India go back, Kashmir ki aazadi ke nare laganewale corruption free india bananyenge..
            Chutiya banana band karo logo ko.. Waise char din ki chandni mili hai enjoy Kar lo. Mahine bhar ke andar media koi aur kanhaiya dhoond legi phir koi poochhega bhi nahi tum logo ko. Aur ye anti corruption ko rahne hi do, ek baar kejriwal chutiya bana diya hai and for ur information CM ke liye kejri hi mera choice tha aur vote bhi diya use par baar baar koi chutiya nahi banta..

          • corruption free India

            Why are you exposing your dumbness by writing more and more?

          • Roy

            Better to be dumb and love ur country than to be educated and be anti national..
            Anyway seeing ur reaction on other peoples comment too and I understand that u people don’t wanna understand mood of the nation so I better leave this conversation..
            Ashamed that people like are not ashamed of themselves..

          • Roy

            Jo khud itne kam logo ke vote se student election jeeta hai uske supporters Modi ki vote ginwa rahe hain..
            Ha ha ha..

          • Roy

            U all are hungry vultures trying to get a flesh out of akhlaq vemula etc. They are nothing but just stepping stone for ur political ambitions.. U had no reply when us 4 questions were replied by another person or when someone showed u the mirror u just called him sanghi. If education makes what u people are then its better I remain illiterate. But won’t let u communist who r ready to sell their motherland live peacefully..
            And pls stop fooling people with this misleading title of us group. U r corrupt minda of India..

          • corruption free India

            Mere knowledge of how to post a message on the net doesn’t develop your logical faculty to think and argue. You will remain a dumb person unless you make some serious efforts to educate yourself. All the best.

    • Binoy Hoskote

      FEW KHAKHI CHEDDIS DON’T REPRESENT POPULATION OF YOUTH OR PEOPLE OF INDIA.MOST OF THOSE COMMENTING HERE ARE UNEDUCATED OR ILLITERATE OR IMMATURE LOLLIPOP LICKING N SUCKING BJP BEGGARS OF LEFTOVERS THEY THROW AROUND. JNU STUDENTS ARE SCHOLARS OF THE HIGHEST CALIBRE,,,,NONE OF THE GOATS HERE ARE EQUICALENT OF EVEN THEIR (JNU STUDENTS SCHOLARS) TOE-NAIL.

    • Binoy Hoskote

      GO JOIN SEARCHING AND COUNTING CONDOMS IN THEIR CAMPUS…BASS, THIS IS THE DEPTHS OF BJP & RSS FROG IN A POND MENTALITY…SO ALSO THE FOOLISH MLA WHO PROBABLY SAT AND COUNTED 3000 CONDOMS HE CAREFULLY LOCATED AND STORED ….

      • Vivek

        LOL ………..Hahahahahahaha……………I guess u got too upset with the Truth about JNU………..Ur language reflect it very much.

        • Binoy Hoskote

          You are demented.

  • Sharad Vohra

    Beautifully written! And you’ve peppered it with “madam” respecting the position, as it must be. Your fingers would have have itched to be be more scathing at some places. Salute

  • Hindusthani

    Wonderful article. You would probably be deemed to be in contempt of court and an anti national. I can imagine how Bhagat Singh would have felt reading the British court judgement against them. I am getting this sinking feeling that if this infection spreads into our government agencies, we may have another freedom struggle in our hands this time, from the pseudo right wing nationalists.

  • Manikandan Vathan

    Dear Mohit,
    .
    Our monarchical judiciary believes that, only courts have the authority for critical enquiry.
    .
    Citizens should shut up and leave it to the institutions of governance namely judiciary and executive.
    .
    Students should only study.
    .
    So don’t mess with a judge.
    .
    Or else u too will land up in jail.
    .
    This is the new mantra of governance.

  • n d sharma

    Judges need refresher courses from time to time so that they can write their judgements precisely and to the point.

  • Vinod Bhandari

    Only one word for this writer. SHAME

    • Binoy Hoskote

      HELL WITH YOU. NO ONE CARES A DAM FOR YOU.

      • Lenny Joseph

        And for you?… heaven? do you think you will find Afzal in heaven?

  • Preethy

    The writer very conveniently skips the very reason he was arrested and talks about everything else. Very misleading article. The writer should know that nothing discussed in the gathering was for the betterment of the nation. Sympathizing terrorists and raising slogans supporting division of the country whose tax payers money you are feeding on for your existence is not going help. I had just wasted my time reading this article and failed to understand how meaningful these people can contribute to India when they just want to divide India.

    • Swathi

      True.

  • Darshan

    Really? Afzal guru ghost haunts them?
    Afzal is a self confessed terrorist. “Kitne afzal maroge? Har ghar se afzal niklega”. So they literally want more terrorists. Slogans for soldiers or country looks so nationalist and devoid of intelligence but see once you sloganeer for a terrorist you place yourself “intellectually superior” place compared to dumb nationalists right?

    This is called disease of intellectual superiority.

  • Naman Jain

    If you read judgements by J. Katju, who has given some very prominent judgments, they often (if not always) include something by Ghalib and certain others. The judgement is an expression of the ‘opinion’ of the court.

    A ‘serious scholar’ talking about judicial killings and then appealing to the same judiciary for help is very plausible to the author somehow.

    • Swathi

      Haha ur right.

  • Binoy Hoskote

    WHAT BJP WITH RSS BEHIND IT IS DOING IS- DESTROYING THE EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS ONE AFTER ANOTHER THROUGH THE ILLITERATE SMRITI IRANI, WHOM LIED REPEATEDLY IN AFFIDvits of her qualificatipons and soon her ‘BHANDA’ WILL BE PHODIFIED…WHEN SHE HAS BEEN ASKED FOR THE FINAL TIME TO SUBMIT HER CLAIMED QUALIFIUCATIONS DOCUMENTS OF B.A. B.COM… & YALE DEGREE BY 15TH MARCH FOR HEARING ON 16 MARCH 2016. WHEN A FINAL DECREE/VERDICT ON THE CASE AGAINST HER WILL BE DECLARED……………..SHE HAS MESSED UP-…. FTII….TRIED MESSING WITH IIM & IIT & GOT A SEVERE BACKLASH THAT KEPT HER SHUT…..THEN SHE MESSED WITH HYDERABAD UNIVERSITY INDIRECTLY BECAME RESPONSIBLE FOR HDRIVING HIM TO SUICIDE……THEN LYING IN PARLIAMENT THAT VEMULA WAS ATTENDED BY DOCTOR FOR DEATH CERTIFICATE WHICH LIE GOT EXPOSED BY CONCERNEWD LADY DOC. (this woman from saas bahu fame sure can lie like hell with a flat face.)…..NO TIME TO WASTE….SHE MESSES UP JNU WITH FABRICATED OPLAQNTED ANTINATIONAL SLOGANSOF BJP[ CLAN ABVP, WHO HAVE VANISHGED FROM THE FACE OF THE EARTH …WITH THE POLICE TOTALLY INEFFICIENTLY LOST IN THE WOILDERNESS- MOSTLY ARM-TWISTED AND PUPPETWERED BYgOVT. IN POWER….WHAT IS NEXT ON HER AGENDA TO MESS UP , ONE WONDERS

    • Swathi

      Sir, ur working for Aam aadmi party, clearly u hv a boosted sense of activism, n ur intensity in tht regard is much appreciated. I hope kejriwal ji gives u a ticket before he goes to pakistan, so tht u can help ppl in India better. But definitely u shd work on ur communication skills because everytime u talk to a person with opposing views, u get angry. U shd stay calm sir as u look aged. Please relax. This country ll develop n progress despite politics, corruption, casteism etc. There re good ppl in India who believe in India first. At the end of the day v shd wonder as to not wt the country has done for us, but what v ve done for this great country. Never let down this patriotic spirit in u, but use it wisely so as to not offend another person.
      Further, i apologize for my sms styled texts, i really dont want to get any Certificate in English from u, n i choose to write short forms. I hope u ll leave me with that liberty.

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    HON’BLE JUSTICE MS PRATIBHA RANI,

    UPON REFUSAL BY MENTIONING OFFICER OF HON’BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA TO MENTION THE MATTER BEFORE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA; LETTER-PETITION BY SENIOR CITIZEN, UNEDUCATED, OBC, VOICELESS RURAL WOMAN TO HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA.

    LETTER-PETITION OF A SENIOR CITIZEN OBC WOMAN THROUGH LINK http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/letterpetition-to-honble-the-chief-justice-of-india

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    COMPLAINT AGAINST MENTIONING OFFICER SUPREME COURT OF INDIA BY SENIOR CITIZEN UNEDUCATED VOICELESS OBC RURAL WOMAN VIDE DIARY NO. 1628250 DATED 12TH OCTOBER 2016

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/complaint-against-mentioning-officer-of-supreme-court-of-india-with-nhrc12102016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Letter-Petition dated 19th August 2016 before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India prior of filing Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016 as the matter involves two states jurisdiction and 498A has been instituted even after the settlement of same matter by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi on 23.07.2013. Hence, matter becomes constitutional and in the interest of larger public.

    Letter petition through link http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/letter-petition-in-supreme-court-of-india-dated-19th-august-2016

    Judgment/Order against Letter petition through Link http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/judgment-against-letter-petition-dated-19th-august-2016-by-the-supreme-court-of-india-vide-diary-no-35529-of-2016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Plight of Petitioner-In-Person in Hon’ble Supreme Court of India And application for Constitution Bench

    Upon direct refusal by mentioning officer to allow the petitioner to mention the matter before Ho’nble the Chief Justice of India as per the provisions laid down in the handbook of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and the schedule listing of the matter fixed by the registry on 21.10.2016; the petitioner has been left with no option but has filed an application for listing Criminal Writ 136 of 2016 before the constitution bench of seven Judges on 18.10.2016 vide diary no. 77878.

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/application-for-listing-before-constitution-bench

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    LETTER-PETITION BEFORE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA AGAINST RAMPANT ATROCITIES ON SENIOR CITIZEN, OXYGEN DEPENDENT, UNEDUCATED, OBC, VOICELESS RURAL WOMAN IN TWO STATES VIZ. BIHAR AS WELL AS IN DELHI SINCE 12 YEARS BY MAFIA AND INDIAN COURTS.

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/letter-petition-dated-13th-october-2016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    True Copy of Writ Criminal Petition 136 of 2016 published for public usage

    Dear All,
    True Copy of Writ Criminal Petition 136 of 2016 filed before Supreme Court of India dated 30th August 2016 And dismissed on 21.10.2016 published for public usage.

    It will give you insight how Apex Court sanctioned the malfunctioning of State Apparatus against a common man & Senior Citizen Woman; violation of principle of Natural Justice; Biased Judiciary ignoring the Constitutional Priority.

    The insight may enable you continue the struggle against malfunctioning of State Apparatus & Strengthening of the Institutions in India.

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/true-copy-of-writ-criminal-petition-136-of-2016-filed-before-supreme-court-of-india-dated-30th-august-2016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    After dismissal of Writ Criminal 136 of 2016 by Apex Court; Lower Court encouraged to continue malfunctioning http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/after-dismissal-of-writ-criminal-136-of-2016-by-apex-court-lower-court-encouraged-to-continue-malfunctioning-24-1016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Apex Court Order for malfunctioning of State Apparatus and against a Common man & Senior Citizen OBC Woman http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/supreme-court-of-india-order-dated-21102016-against-writ-petition-criminal-136-of-2016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    a. That the Order dated 21.10.2016 in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016 by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India violated the Part IV of ORDER XXXV of Supreme Court Rules, 1966 which was framed in exercise of the powers conferred by Article 145 of the Constitution. Provision of the Part IV of Order XXXV of Supreme Court Rules, 1966 says, “1.(1) Every petition under Article 32 of the Constitution shall be in writing and shall be heard by a Division Court of not less than five Judges provided that a petition which does not raise a substantial question of Law as to the interpretation of the Constitution may be heard and decided by a Division Court of less than five Judges, and, during vacation, by the vacation Judge sitting singly. (2) All interlocutory and miscellaneous applications connected with a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution, may be heard and decided by a Division Court of less than five Judges, and, during vacation, by the vacation Judge sitting singly, notwithstanding that in the petition a substantial question of Law as to the interpretation of Constitution is raised.”
    b. That the Writ Petition which has been dismissed by the Order, against which Review Petition is hereby moved, did raise ‘substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution and this Hon’ble Court was not required to decide any ‘interlocutory and miscellaneous application’ ‘connected with the petition’. The humble Petitioner had submitted this in his Writ Petition, pleadings/arguments and through written submission followed by interlocutory application for constitution bench on 18.10.2016 vide diary no. 77878.
    c. That a well-designed criminal conspiracy being commissioned and strategy being adopted against the petitioner by the Quasi-Judicial Officer of this Hon’ble Court to spoil the valid ground of the case and make it liable to be dismissal with liberty by this Hon’ble Court and to close the door of the Hon’ble Apex Court under Article 32 for enforcement of guaranteed fundamental right of the petitioner under Article 21.

    A True Copy of Review Petition Criminal in Writ petition Criminal No.136 of 2016 before Supreme Court of India filed on 09.11.2016

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/review-petition-criminal-in-writ-petition-criminal-no136-of-2016-before-supreme-court-of-india-filed-on-09112016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Dear All,

    DOES THIS CASE NEED CERTIFICATE BY SR. ADVOCATE TO CURE GROSS MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE?

    CURATIVE PETITION CRIMINAL WITHOUT CERTIFICATE BY Sr. ADVOCATE violating Rupa Ashok Hurra Vs Ashok Hurra ; valid reason at para 15 of the petition

    Curative petition criminal before supreme court of India has been filed on 09.12.2016 vide diary no. 41026 WITHOUT certificate by Sr. Advocate violating the the guidelines laid down in Rupa Ashok Hurra Vs Ashok Hurra 2002 (4) SCC 388. It is further submitted under para 15 of the Curative Petition Criminal that the Certificate by Sr. Advocate has not been filed by the petitioner because of the valid and unavoidable reasons which has been caused by this Hon’ble Court. The petitioner has been pushed into the Curative stage intentionally by this Hon’ble Court to close the door of this Hon’ble Court for the petitioner no.01 and 02 in the garb of certificate by Sr. Advocate, as the petitioner had refused to engage any legal Aid Advocate against this matter in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016. The mentioning officer of this Hon’ble Court has stopped the petitioner no.02 who was eligible to mention the matter before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India’s court and Registry has circulated unregistered Interlocutory Application for constitution bench dated 18.10.2016 vide diary no. 77878 in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016. Further Registry has suppressed the record of application dated 03.10.2016 for urgent mentioning of the matter and urgent relief sought before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India filed by the petitioner on behalf of petitioner no.02 as per the guidelines and grounds laid down in the Handbook of this Hon’ble Court. Registry did not surrender the file before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India’s Court which has been disclosed through certified copy of the office report dated 20.10.2016 in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016. Hence, Mentioning Officer and Registry both have spoiled the valid ground of Constitution bench and mentioning the matter before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India’s Court to make it liable to be dismissed with liberty by the two judge bench violating the Order XXXV of Supreme Court Rule 1966. In other words, petitioner has been pushed into the Curative stage intentionally by this Hon’ble Court to close the door of this Hon’ble Court for the petitioner no.01 and 02 in the garb of certificate by Sr. Advocate, as the petitioner had refused to engage any legal Aid Advocate against this matter in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016; which has resulted in gross miscarriage of justice. In view of the above mentioned circumstances, Petitioner no. 01 and 02 has been left with no option but to survive or may not survive at the mercy of the GOD.
    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/curative-petition-criminal-before-supreme-court-of-india-filed-on-09122016-vide-diary-no-41026

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/curative-petition-criminal-registered-before-sc

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Dear All,

    Certified Copy of Office Report disclosed Well designed Criminal Conspiracy by Registrar X of SC

    A well-designed criminal conspiracy being commissioned and strategy being adopted against the petitioner by the Quasi-Judicial Officer of this Hon’ble Court to spoil the valid ground of the case and make it liable to be dismissal with liberty by this Hon’ble Court and to close the door of the Hon’ble Apex Court under Article 32 for enforcement of guaranteed fundamental right of the petitioner under Article 21

    Certified copy of the office report dated 20.10.2016 in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016 issued by Registrar Section X of Supreme Court of India has disclosed that Registry has not surrender th pg e file before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India’s Court. It has been disclosed that Registry has suppressed the record of application dated 03.10.2016 for urgent mentioning of the matter and urgent relief sought before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India filed by the petitioner on behalf of petitioner no.02 as per the guidelines and grounds laid down in the Handbook of this Hon’ble Court.

    Further it has also been disclosed through Office report that the Registry has circulated unregistered Interlocutory Application for constitution bench dated 18.10.2016 vide diary no. 77878 in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016 to spoil the ground of constitution bench and to make it liable to be dismissed by two judge bench to push the petitioner into the Curative stage intentionally to close the door of this Hon’ble Court for the petitioner no.01 and 02 in the garb of Certificate by Sr. Advocate, as the petitioner had refused to engage any legal Aid Advocate against this matter in Writ Petition Criminal 136 of 2016.

    FIND ATTACHED CERTIFIED COPY OF OFFICE REPORT DATED 20.10.2016 IN WRIT PETITION CRIMINAL 136 OF 2016 ISSUED BY THE REGISTRAR SECTION X OF SUPREME COURT OF INDIA.

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/be4a0c736608a974689869089e4aa2f58f01c192cb9b4b0428179dab1a6396d9.jpg

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a9e48228032efd4249894b8ef871ace6c6b1012e4bca6e36b31a7ba5ebefdcb8.j

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/ab5eb34d245e951787c7a13adb9fc474d4576ce56fe4cd24315a89b4044f0518.jpg

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a9e48228032efd4249894b8ef871ace6c6b1012e4bca6e36b31a7ba5ebefdcb8.jpg
    http://seniorcitizenrights.blogspot.in/2016/11/is-targeting-senior-citizens-role-of.html?spref=tw

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Evidence against Nexus of Rtd Justice S.B. Sinha & Praveen Kumar (IDAS) to kill us

    Nexus of Rtd. Justice S.B. Sinha and Praveen Kumar (IDAS) involved into this 12 years long matter to kill me and my Oxygen dependent mother in the defense area of Palam New Delhi and to usurp our property in Bihar has been apprised to the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India through SLP(C) no. 9854/2012, SLP(C) no. 9483/2013, SLP(C) no. 19073/2013, Writ (C) 90 of 2016, Writ (Crl.) 136 of 2016, Review (Crl.) 825 of 2016 and Curative (Crl.) vide diary no. 41026; Hon’ble prime Minister of India through PMOPG/E/2016/0599866 dated 22.12.2016; Hon’ble President of India through PRSEC/E/2016/16154 dated 30.12.2016; Secretary General Supreme Court of India and Controller General Defense Accounts (CGDA), Government of India through email dated 28.12.2016 to take appropriate action against Rtd. Justice S.B. Sinha and Praveen Kumar (IDAS).

    EVIDENCES OF NEXUS OF RTD JUSTICE S.B. SINHA AND PRAVEEN KUMAR (IDAS) HAVE BEEN ENCLOSED WITH THIS POST IN 13 PAGES AND 29 PARA ONLY THROUGH BELOW LINK

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/communication-with-secretary-general-of-supreme-court-of-india-dated-31122016-70597654

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/evidence-of-nexus-of-rtd-justice-sb-sinha-and-praveen-kumar-idas-to-secretary-general-of-supreme-court-of-india-by-om-prakash-dated-31122016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    RTI against Supreme Court of India dated 05.01.2017 for protecting and shielding BAD ELEMENTS OF STATE APPARATUS and harassing, offending, victimizing Common man and Woman

    BELOW RTI LINK
    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-against-supreme-court-of-india-dated-05012017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    RTI Request against CIC New Delhi dated 5.1.2017 for Non-implementation of Section 7(1) of RTI Act 2005

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-request-against-cic-dated-512017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    LAST RESORT…….LAST RESORT…….LAST RESORT……….

    Writ Criminlal No……….of 2017 titled “OM PRAKASH & ANR VS. UNION OF INDIA & ORS” filed on 18.1.2017 Vide Diary No. 2188 against Supreme Court of India for Evading the Rule of Law; Violating set practice, procedure as laid down in the Handbook of this Hon’ble Court; protecting/shielding Bad Elements of State Apparatus and offending, harassing, victimizing the Petitioner-in Person and his Senior Citizen old age Oxygen dependent mother.
    This happens to be last resort under legal remedy before the COURT OF LAW.

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/writ-criminlal-noof-2017-titled-om-prakash-anr-vs-union-of-india-ors-filed-on-1812017-vide-diary-no-2188-before-supreme-court-of-india-with-276-pages

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Writ Criminal against Registrar of Supreme Court of India for refusal to register Writ Criminal against Union of India under Article 32 of Constitution of India

    http://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/writ-petition-criminal-noof-2017-vide-dno3913-against-registrar-supreme-court-of-india-for-lodgement-of-writ-criminal-dno2188-of-2017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    APPEAL BY WAY OF MOTION AGAINST THE LODGEMENT ORDER DATED 16.02.2017 VIDE D.NO.3913 OF 2017 ISSUED BY REGISTRAR SUPREME COURT OF INDIA UNDER ORDER XV RULE 5 OF THE SUPREME COURT RULES, 2013.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/appeal-against-lodgement-order-of-registrar-supreme-court-of-india-under-order-xv-rule-5-of-supreme-court-rules-2013

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    BRUTALITY BY HIGHER COURTS JUDGES AGAINST A COMMON MAN & WOMAN

    WITHOUT ACTUAL RESPONDENT/OPPOSITE PARTY

    FOR THE SAME CAUSE OF ACTION

    SINCE 2004……….2010………TILL DATE…………………

    PHOTO ENTRY PASS FOR COURT ROOMS (SINCE 2012 TO TILL DATE)

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/brutality-by-higher-courts-judges-against-a-common-man-without-actual-respondentopposite-party-since-2012

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    RTI reply by Additional Registrar & CPIO , Supreme Court of India dated 04.02.2017 against Violation of set practice, procedure and rules by the Registrar of this Hon’ble Court as laid down in the Handbook of this Hon’ble Court

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-against-supreme-court-of-india-dated-05012017

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-reply-by-addl-registrar-cpio-supreme-court-of-india-dated-04022017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Listing Performa dated 23.02.2017 D.NO. 17593 of 2017 against Criminal Appeal against Denial of access to Justice by the Registrar Supreme Court of India

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/application-for-listing-performa-against-appeal-against-denial-of-access-to-justice-by-registrar-supreme-court-of-india-dated-23022017-dno-17593-of-2017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Registrar Admin & FAA , Supreme Court of India refused to reply against Violation of set practice, procedure and rules by the Registrar in the garb of JUDICIAL ORDER OR INTERPRETATION OF LAW against Eight Questions pertaining to the act of QUASI JUDICIAL OFFICER, Registrar Misc & Mentioning Officer in connection with three Applications dated 03.10.2016; dated 06.10.2016 and dated 18.10.2016 filed by the petitioners against Writ Criminal 136 of 2016 which have been either suppressed or spoiled by the Registrar Misc and Mentioning Officer and not placed before the Court of Law to make the Writ Criminal 136 of 2016 liable to be dismissed by two judges’ bench.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/reply-by-faa-supreme-court-of-india-dated-23022017
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/9a5de6ec816ba6babdd4b13c6bcdc9df3765f5520248223ed43cc5226b244325.jpg https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/d7d00e1cbe2a03c6263237980fe477aaf97442662cc7e96fc2989681c36850c6.jpg https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/8d632868793b18d1cca9ff82941cd9f247524cf753a37ec3a30aabe615c55c9b.jpg https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/258670d11806f806bce182ee5e0766bd489fcaacf5ea7b8e934b0fca8689724c.jpg https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/6be87fc5bb19731eb6cda37dd186d26140417132912875b292d723af834bcc31.jpg https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-against-supreme-court-of-india-dated-05012017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Objection Letter to Registrar Supreme Court of India for Spoiling the Genuine “NINE RELIEFS” of the Petitioners dated 2nd march 2017
    Reply against NOTICE of Hearing for 27.03.2017 dated 01.03.2017 issued by Section X Supreme Court of India and prayer for withdrawal/correction of forcible NOTICE dated 01.03.2017 and issuance of NOTICE for appearance against D.NO. 16166 of 2017 and D.NO. 17593 of 2017 for urgent relief-reg.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/objection-letter-to-registrar-sci-for-spoiling-the-genuine-relief-of-the-petitioners-dated-2nd-march-2017
    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/writ-criminlal-noof-2017-titled-om-prakash-anr-vs-union-of-india-ors-filed-on-1812017-vide-diary-no-2188-before-supreme-court-of-india-with-276-pages

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Application for defending Human Rights before Hon’ble Supreme Court of India vide D.NO. 19917 dated 03.03.2017

    Crl. M.P. NO…….of 2017 Vide D.NO. 19917 dated 03.03.2017 against Curative Petition (Criminal) D 41026 of 2016
    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/crl-mp-noof-2017-vide-dno-19917-dated-03032017-against-curative-petition-criminal-d-41026-of-2016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Aggrieved by the reply of Registrar (Admin) & FAA, Supreme Court of India dated 23.02.2017, appellant preferred Second Appeal against Registrar of Supreme Court of India D.No. 113204 dated 27.02.2017 before CIC of New Delhi.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/second-appeal-against-registrar-of-supreme-court-of-india-dno-113204-dated-27022017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR
  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    MATTER BEGINS FROM 2004 WHILE NHRC WRITES 1991

    MINDLESS REPLY BY NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION’S DATED 2.12.2016 AGAINST A COMPLAINT OF SENIOR CITIZEN OXYGEN DEPENDENT RURAL AND UNEDUCATED WIDOW WOMAN

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/national-human-rights-commissions-reply-dated-2122016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    First appeal under RTI Act 2005 against Registrar (J-I) Supreme Court of India for REFUSAL OF REGISTRATION OF WRIT CRIMINAL AGAINST UNION OF INDIA D.NO.2188 OF 2017

    Aggrieved by the reply of Adl. Registrar & CPIO, Supreme Court of India dated 04.03.2017, appellant preferred First Appeal against CPIO of Supreme Court of India dated 07.03.2017 before Ld. Registrar (Admin) & First Appellate Authority (FAA) Supreme Court of India at New Delhi.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/first-appeal-under-rti-act-2005-against-registrar-ji-supreme-court-of-india-for-refusal-of-registration-of-writ-criminal-against-union-of-india-dno2188-of-2017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    GIFT OF INERNATIONAL WOMAN’S DAY !!!

    SUPREME COURT OF INDIA REFUSES TO REGISTER RURAL POOR AGED INFIRM WOMAN’S WRIT CRIMINAL AGAINST UNION OF INDIA

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/first-appeal-under-rti-act-2005-against-registrar-ji-supreme-court-of-india-for-refusal-of-registration-of-writ-criminal-against-union-of-india-dno2188-of-2017-dated-08032017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Hon’ble President of India Transferred a Complaint No. PRSEC/E/2016/16154 against Rtd. Justice S.B. Sinha & Praveen Kumar (IDAS) to Ministry of Home Affairs dated 08.03.2017

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/president-of-india-transferred-complaint-no-prsece201616154-to-ministry-of-home-affairs-dated-08032017 https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/complaint-no-prsece201616154-dated-30122016

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    HON’BLE PRESIDENT OF INDIA FORWARDED A COMPLAINT AGAINST DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ON 09.03.2017 FOR ITS REFUSAL TO INTERVENE INTO THE MATTER AS IT IS SUB-JUDICE.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/honble-president-of-india-forwarded-complaint-to-department-of-justice-dated-02022017

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    Department of Justice refused to reply against a Complaint no. PRSEC/E/2017/01470 dated 02.02.2017 forwarded by Hon’ble President of India

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/department-of-justice-reply-against-complaint-no-prsece201701470-73027448

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    GROUND ZERO REALITY OF ANTI-CORRUPTION INSTITUTIONS IN INDIA

    Central Registry CIC New Delhi did not take any action rather suppressed the record against Registrar Admin Patna High Court under the complaint u/s 18(1) of RTI Act 2005 since 06.08.2016.

    Central Registry of CIC protected & shielded the Bad elements of State Apparatus and offended victimized the poor ailing common woman and man.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/final-status-of-rti-request-dated-17032017-against-central-registry-cic-new-delhi

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    LOOK AT THE LUMPEN-ISM OF DEPARTMENT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS, MINISTRY OF LAW & JUSTICE, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

    RTI request to Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India dated 14.08.2016. Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India refused to forward or reply and returned the RTI request dated 16.08.2016

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-request-to-molaj-dated-14082016

    First Appeal to Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India dated 03.09.2016. Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India remained silent since 03.09.2016 to till date.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/first-appeal-to-molaj-dated-03092016

    Online Complaint against Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India dated 16.08.2016 before CIC, New Delhi

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/online-complaint-against-molaj-dated-16082016

    CIC New Delhi admitted Complaint u/s 18(1) of RTI Act 2005 against Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India vide File No. CIC/MOLAJ/C/2016/299945 dated 28.112016 and still pending before CIC New Delhi.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/cic-new-delhi-admitted-comlaint-vide-166020-against-molaj

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    LOOK AT THE LUMPEN-ISM OF INDIAN ANTI-CORRUPTION INSTITUTIONS OF GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

    Central Registry of Central Information Commission Government of India supplied false reply dated 07.03.2017 killing and distorting the basic fabric of the provision section 7 (1) of RTI Act 2005.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/reply-of-central-registry-cic-new-delhi-dated-7032017

    Bare Act of Right to Information Act 2005.

    Section 7 in The Right To Information Act, 2005

    7. Disposal of request.—
    (1) Subject to the proviso to sub section (2) of section 5 or the proviso to sub¬-section (3) of section 6, the Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be on receipt of a request under section 6 shall, as expeditiously as possible, and in any case within thirty days of the receipt of the request, either provide the information on payment of such fee as may be prescribed or reject the request for any of the reasons specified in sections 8 and 9: Provided that where the information sought for concerns the life or liberty of a person, the same shall be provided within forty eight hours of the receipt of the request.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/section-7-sub-clause-1-of-rti-act-2005

    “The non-supply of the information may either lead to death or grievous injury to the concerned person. Liberty of a person is threatened if she or he is going to be incarcerated or has already been incarcerated and the disclosure of the information may change that situation. If the disclosure of the information would obviate the danger then it may be considered under the proviso of Section 7(1). The imminent danger has to be demonstrably proven”.
    Hence, NON-SUPPLY of information regarding N.B.W dated 08.09.2011 u/s 83 Cr.Pc. which has been kept secret under the Judicature of Patna High Court may lead to death or grievous injury to the concerned person.

    Thus, CIC involved in planned murder of a common woman and man.

  • OM PRAKASH PODDAR

    SUPREME COURT OF INDIA AGAIN VIOLATED HUMAN RIGHTS & PETITIONER’S RIGHTS

    Registrar Misc. Supreme Court of India again offended the petitioner’s Right and Violated the Human Rights by way of forcible Registration of defective matter, forcible issuance of NOTICE, forcible direction for removal of prayer (b) and forcible listing of defective Curative (Criminal) D 41026 of 2016 before Hon’ble Judges in Chambers on 27.03.2017.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/rti-dated-23032017-against-sc

    Petitioner’s reply to the Notification of defects letter vide Diary No. 5356/2016/X dated 23.03.2017 issued by Registrar Misc. Section X Supreme Court of India against withdrawal application of Curative Criminal D 41026 of 2016.

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/reply-to-the-notification-of-defects-letter-vide-diary-no-5356-2016x-dated-230317

  • WIDOW ASHA RANI DEVI

    Second Appeal against Registrar, CIC New Delhi for Non-implementation of Section 7(1) of RTI Act 2005 in second appeal Diary no. 183722 dated 03.11.2016 (Registrar Admin, Patna High Court, FAA)

    https://www.slideshare.net/OmPrakashPoddar/second-appeal-against-registrar-cic-dated-24032017